The Urban Flavour (part1)
Friday March 04th 2005, 8:26 pm . Filed under: Uncategorized

At times i get very disillusioned at the lack of an artsy visual culture in this city…i find myself repeatedly bringing up the point that maybe … just maybe… if this city had more of a ‘pedestrian’ culture than a ‘mall and vehicle’ culture — there would be more opportunities to explore art and design. Then again, every city has its own urban flavour and expecting it to be similar to other cities seems not only unfair but a rather derogatory attempt to homogenize and standardize.

“Every society gets the visual environment it deserves. Doesn’t it?” (from the Preface of David Carson’s ‘End of Print’)

Always liked that question, but also always found myself probing further into the real meaning of the statement…
What did it REALLY mean ??
What would it mean in context to a Dubaian society?
What would it mean in context to an artsy visual culture in Dubai?
What visual environment does Dubai deserve?

To me, the words ‘visual environment’ refers to the environment that one encounters whilst interacting with a city. It is the fabric that gives meaning and substance to an individual who is engaged in a quest to experience his/her environment. In the case of modern city like Dubai, there are two coexisting environments.

On the surface, Dubai’s visual environment would essentially be zing-zing buildings, varooom cars and bigger-brighter billboards all contributing to the even louder ‘kachhhiiiiingggg!!’ of an extremely successful cashregister economy.
The Dubaian society essentially is a very colorful multicultural one and therefore to say that ‘every society gets the visual environment it deserves’ would logically mean that it deserves a visual environment that essentially speaks to many cultures in unison such as the language of business and money perhaps.

Under the surface however lies multiple unique visual environments born out of various cultures that have attempted to settle themselves in this city over the years. It is here, where different cultures have found a niche market and it is here where a ‘chutnification’ takes place on an aesthetic level. (Salman Rushdie popularly used the term ‘chutnification’ to describe this phenomena of modern multiculturalism – i quite like the word)

In the next couple of posts, i’ll try and deal with this idea of chutnification from an aesthetic point of view and see where i go with it. I think this post has drained my brain a little too much – too much theorizing and over analyzing kinda spoils the fun of free blogging…

watch out for ‘the urban flavour (part2)


  • http://www.livejournal.com/users.ishtyle Ish

    an excellent topic of discussion. What I find interesting in your description of Dubai is it’s dual quality, a sort of ‘double-layering’ characterizing the visual environment of the city. Whereas, in some cases you won’t find clear ‘layers’ as such.. but a somewhat forced harmony between what we deem to be modernity and culturalism (multi- or bi- or what have you). And a lot of that is dictated by what sells. I recall a painful episode in Olympia, Greece: Here we are.. in Olympia.. it is beautiful, it is sunny, the very air has history in it. Each building, each ruin.. carrying with it thousands of years. And then there is Mr. Gupta, a fellow tourist.. who says “yahaan pe casino kahaan hai?” (“where’s the casino here?”) You want to slap Mr Gupta but also realise that a bunch of people out there don’t recognise (perhaps dont’ want to reecognise) multicultural visual environments. They feel safe and comfortable knowing there is a mall nearby. And sadly… these people may also be the majority whose demands dictate the visual environments of (past!), present and future cities. There should be a revolutionary movement of people like us against standardization and homogenization. I’ll design the t-shirts.

  • http://www.livejournal.com/users/ishtyle Ish

    in the world of faux pas, I am queen. I just realised that you and mr. gupta share the same last name. You are uber-cool, absolutely super :)
    That mr. Gupta, he was so uncool.. for eg he kept saying ‘in our delhi this.. in our delhi that’ and he kept looking for indian restaurants.. in Greece! Can you imagine?

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/1743733 Amrit(raj)

    in the world of faux pas – ish … you truly are the queen !!
    ‘… slap Mr.Gupta’ ??? – for a moment there you broke my heart to infinitely tiny pieces… but i know now what you meant ;)

    you raise a very interesting point in your comment ish – essentially you are saying that Mr.G looking for a casino is doing so primarily because he feels that every city is inherently characterized with a casino, a mall and a mcdonalds around the corner. He enquires not out of mockery.. but simply out of habit of being exposed to the ‘standard ciy’ and hence fails to catch attention of the unique visual environment inherent to the city….. BUT… dont you also think that maybe his query into the whereabouts of a casino shows his subconcious acceptance of a multicultural visual environment ??? in an otherwise popular and historically rich city of Greece ??

    to him – experiencing yet another ‘standard city’ in a different geographic location is primary and the unique visual environment is only of secondary importance….

    People coming to Dubai want to experience the richness and lavish lifestyle of the Madinat Jumeirah or the Burj Al Arab which is truly arab and modern… but end up overlooking the back alleys, the dingy textile stores, the iranian tyre shops, the bangladeshi fish market – where the true mix of two cultures have taken place. A biculturalism that is as important to this city as its arabness.

    i dont know… i guess the double layering theory makes it kinda complicated … but there is definitely a dual layer if not more…

    i better get back to work now – appreciate your thoughtful comment ish.. thanks!!